It was built by donations and subscriptions by the local townspeople. It opened in 1893 and the minister provided services at all three of the San Lorenzo Valley Presbyterian Churches. The article highlights one of the more beloved ministers as David Taylor from Scotland, who with his two daughters built up the congregation. The building was replaced with a bigger building later and the property was eventually purchased to build a house on it by Nick Belardi. After his wife died tragically he donated the church and the land to the town in her honor.